Some losses are etched in memory due to the anguish they cause. Others are remembered for the greatness that was never realized.
For 55 minutes in Atlanta, England and Argentina appeared poised to deliver a semifinal match worthy of the World Cup stage. Anthony Gordon’s excellent goal, set up by Morgan Rogers’ sharp pass, put England in the lead with over 35 minutes left in regulation. Argentina struggled to contain Lionel Messi, and the South Americans found themselves chasing the game, making it seem like a night that could become legendary in the world of football.
However, it never materialized. Not because Argentina was unstoppable, but because England lost faith in the style of play that had brought them success.
Instead of capitalizing on their lead, England spent the last half-hour attempting to defend it. They conceded ground, abandoned the counter-attacking strategy that had unsettled Argentina, and gradually allowed the game to drift closer to their own goal. By the time they recognized the threat, they had lost their momentum.
In doing so, they robbed themselves and the spectators of the high-stakes match that this occasion warranted.
The irony is hard to overlook. England brought in Thomas Tuchel because they believed he could excel in the most significant tactical battles. Yet, when the defining tactical challenge arose, he veered away from the very game plan that had given England control.
Once the opening goal was scored, the match unfolded precisely as England would have envisioned before the game started: Argentina was forced to attack, creating spaces for England’s pace to take advantage of.
Instead, the German manager shifted the dynamics. The attacking drive faded, England retreated deeper, and for the last 25 minutes, Tuchel effectively utilized six defenders to safeguard a slim one-goal lead.
Bukayo Saka remained on the sidelines. Marcus Rashford was introduced at the last moment. Noni Madueke never made it onto the pitch. England’s primary asset throughout the tournament—speed and directness in transition—was abruptly sacrificed in favor of preserving a delicate 1-0 lead.
Against Messi’s Argentina, that was a perilous risk. And it turned out to be disastrous.
However, this was not solely Tuchel’s misstep. The players themselves articulated what transpired.
“After we went 1-0 up, it felt like we were just trying to hold on, which isn’t sufficient at this level,” captain Harry Kane reflected afterward.
“We ought to have continued pressing forward,” noted Marc Guehi, who added: “It felt like we scored and then the mentality shifted to retreating and defending.”
Dan Burn shared a similar viewpoint.
“I believed we executed the game plan well until we scored,” he remarked. “We became a bit passive after the goal, defended perhaps too deep, and the quality of chances that Argentina began creating made it seem like it was only a matter of time.”
The players fell back along with the manager. Collectively, England accepted the invitation to defend rather than maintain their attacking momentum. They ceased to pose questions to Argentina and instead focused on weathering the responses.
At the highest levels of football, such a mentality rarely yields positive results for long.
By the time the hour mark arrived, Messi had begun to find space that England had previously denied him. Enzo Fernandez took charge of the play from midfield. Jordan Pickford found himself increasingly occupied.
Argentina began to smell victory. Meanwhile, England resembled a team merely waiting for the final whistle instead of aiming to score the goal that would have secured the match.
What made the aftermath even more unsettling was Tuchel’s refusal to acknowledge any of it.
“If it doesn’t end well, it’s easy to claim my decisions were wrong,” he stated. “I have no regrets. We played one of our best matches, possibly the best.”
No regrets?
Managers are compensated to make tough decisions in challenging moments. They will certainly make mistakes. What they cannot afford is to insist that nothing went awry when the evidence suggests otherwise.
History has a cruel way of catching up with England when the stakes are highest. They are now the only nation this century to score first in two World Cup semifinals and lose both, having also relinquished a lead against Croatia in 2018.
Different coach. Different era. The same self-inflicted conclusion.
Gordon’s goal should have opened the door to one of the great World Cup semifinals. Instead, England quietly shut it on themselves.
Sixty years after 1966, England can no longer claim to lack talent as an excuse. This generation possesses the skill to defeat any opponent. The lingering question is whether, when history finally grants them the moment they have long awaited, they will have the courage to trust the football that brought them to this point.
Until they do, the pain will persist.
