Within the historic imperial garden of Zhongnanhai, Chinese President Xi Jinping aimed to impress US President Donald Trump with ancient trees that predate the United States.
“That larger one over there is 400 years old,” Xi remarked on May 15, gesturing towards a tree while the two leaders walked through the area that acts as the Communist Party’s headquarters, accompanied only by their interpreters.
“Observe the vitality and history on display!” Xi emphasized, using both hands to illustrate his point.
This moment highlighted a significant message Xi wished to convey during Trump’s visit: both leaders are at a pivotal point in history and share a responsibility to guide their nations away from conflict.
The day prior, at the Temple of Heaven, Xi had expressed optimism that China and the US could avoid the Thucydides Trap, a theory suggesting that tensions arise between a rising power and an established one.
Back among the trees in Zhongnanhai, Trump engaged with his host.
“Wow, they can live that long,” he commented. He then inquired how frequently Xi had shown the garden to other foreign dignitaries, seemingly interested in the exclusivity of the experience.
“Very rarely,” replied the Chinese leader.
It is possible Xi was unaware that Trump is not particularly sentimental about trees. Last year, long-standing magnolias honoring presidents Warren Harding and Franklin D. Roosevelt were removed from the White House grounds to accommodate his envisioned grand ballroom.
This incident reflects the disconnect between the two leaders. While Xi considers historical context and the responsibilities of a great power, Trump tends to evaluate situations based on immediate benefits.
So, who emerged victorious in this latest diplomatic face-off between the two most influential figures globally?
By various indicators, both can claim a victory.
Xi asserted that he had convinced Trump to agree on a new framework for China-US relations aimed at fostering a “constructive and strategically stable” partnership.
As Professor Zhu Feng from Nanjing University explained to The Straits Times, the concept of strategic stability originated during the Cold War, when the US and the Soviet Union maintained a balance through the threat of mutually assured nuclear destruction.
In contrast, Xi’s post-Cold War interpretation of strategic stability seeks to promote constructive cooperation rather than destructive rivalry, emphasizing collaboration as a priority while keeping competition within limits.
This also indicates how Beijing wants Washington to perceive China: not merely as a subordinate partner, but as an equal competitor, or frenemy, alongside the US.
Trump, too, could assert that he “won” something. He announced what he described as Beijing’s willingness to assist with the Iran situation, although the specifics of China’s potential involvement remain ambiguous.
From another angle, however, neither leader truly “won” anything.
There was no noticeable shift in Washington’s stance on Taiwan, despite Xi making it clear that this is Beijing’s primary concern.
Trump also did not secure the significant trade agreements he may have hoped for.
While he mentioned that China had agreed to purchase 200 Boeing aircraft, that figure was lower than anticipated. No exact numbers for agricultural or energy acquisitions have been disclosed to date.
Viewed from this perspective, the win-lose dichotomy may be too simplistic for comprehending the broader benefits from the first American presidential visit to China in nearly ten years.
Stability itself is a positive outcome. “The world benefits,” stated Professor Yang Dali of the University of Chicago to ST, as any meeting that reduces tensions between Washington and Beijing would offer the global community some much-needed relief.
Furthermore, this was merely the initial encounter in what could be a year filled with Xi-Trump meetings. Why rush to declare a victor when the game is ongoing?
Should Xi accept Trump’s invitation to visit the US in September, if Trump returns to China for Apec in November, and if Xi attends the Group of 20 summit in Florida in December, they could potentially meet four times in 2026.
This might clarify why this summit produced few tangible outcomes, which appeared scant. Both parties may be “rationing” diplomatic concessions to ensure there is enough to last until the end of the year.
It was always unrealistic to anticipate a grand agreement. A hastily arranged visit was unlikely to resolve a structural rivalry that spans technology, trade, and security.
Instead, ensuring the optics were favorable was more crucial. Both sides needed to demonstrate to the world that they could coexist harmoniously, and that each leader had something to present to their domestic constituencies.
Above all, there was mutual flattery. Trump referred to Xi as a great leader and brought along a group of top executives, including Tesla’s Elon Musk and Nvidia’s Jensen Huang, providing Beijing with the high-profile endorsement from worldwide businesses it sought.
Xi, in turn, went all out, organizing a welcome ceremony complete with goose-stepping honor guards and military displays that Trump is known to admire.
There were also more personal gestures. During the welcome ceremony, Xi seemed to take his time with Eric Trump, the president’s second son and an executive vice-president of the Trump Organization. Beijing recognizes that with Trump, personal flattery is most effective when it resonates on a familial level.
In a final tribute to the visiting president, the last song played at the state banquet was “YMCA,” a song synonymous with Trump’s rallies and an unofficial anthem of his campaign.
Back in the former imperial garden in Zhongnanhai, Trump, known for his sensitivity to flattery, appeared pleased to discover from Xi that very few foreign leaders had been granted access to the exclusive grounds where China’s leaders operate and where Mao Zedong resided for 27 years.
What he may be unaware of is that Xi also hosted Vladimir Putin for tea in the same compound in May 2024. At the end of that meeting, state television footage captured Xi embracing the Russian leader – the kind of “big, fat hug” that Trump had anticipated from Xi but did not receive this time.
Putin is reportedly scheduled to arrive in Beijing shortly after Trump’s departure. The timing is significant. Beijing seeks to engage with Washington without diminishing its relationship with Moscow, aiming to position itself as the essential power able to communicate with all parties on its own terms.
In the realm of great-power diplomacy, everyone wants to feel exceptional, but the ancient trees in Zhongnanhai have witnessed enough to understand otherwise.
